New Buffalo

Find 3-Star Hotels in New Buffalo

✓ Trusted by 300M+ travellers ✓ 1.8M+ daily users ✓ 147M+ verified reviews ✓ 24/7 support in 30 seconds

Swipe down to view more
Filter by:
Hotel Star Rating
≤2345
Guest Rating
9+8+7+6+

Compare Best 3-Star Hotels in New Buffalo with Prices & Reviews

Select your travel dates to compare the latest 3 star hotels prices in New Buffalo, check availability, guest reviews, locations, and available deals to find the best stay.
Most Booked
Lowest price
Closest to downtown
Highest Rated
79
Hotels in New Buffalo
Our New Buffalo Hotel's Location is PerfectWhether you're in Harbor County for a Lake Michigan vacation or stopping along I-94 on your way to Chicago or Detroit, the Holiday Inn Express New Buffalo is the ideal hotel. The sandy beaches of Lake Michigan are just 1.5 miles away, and our quiet location off exit 1 of I-94 makes travel simple.For a stress-free vacation, our New Buffalo hotel's guests can enjoy fun in the sun at area beaches, as well as easy access to the attractions of Harbor County. Save a day to tour the Michigan wine trail and shop the many antique stores. Or, try your luck at Four Winds Casino, only 1.5 miles from our front door. Don't miss a quiet stroll along the shore of our great lake, too.Business guests traveling to Chicago or Detroit appreciate that our New Buffalo hotel has fast and easy access to I-94 at exit 1. Our quiet surroundings, business amenities like free high-speed, wireless Internet access and our meeting room are great reasons to stop in New Buffalo.No matter what brings you to Lake Michigan, our hotel's amenities are designed to pamper you. Send vacation photos with the free Internet access, or enjoy swimming in our sparkling, indoor pool year-round. There's a Fitness Center to keep up your healthy routines and a free, hot breakfast served each morning. Our cozy rooms and professional service create the perfect Michigan vacation oasis. Our New Buffalo hotel's staff is waiting to welcome you.

"Very clean. Value for money"
Very Good
91 reviews
8.8/10
1 night
From PLN 556
Check availability
49
Hotels in New Buffalo
With a stay at New Buffalo Inn in New Buffalo (Downtown New Buffalo), you'll be within a 15-minute drive of Lake Michigan and Four Winds Casino New Buffalo. This chalet is 11.6 mi (18.6 km) from Indiana Dunes National Park and 9.5 mi (15.3 km) from Blue Chip Casino. Free self parking is available onsite. Make yourself at home in one of the 9 guestrooms.
Great
42 reviews
9.0/10
1 night
From PLN 1,039
Check availability
20
Hotels in New Buffalo
**Welcome to Your Comfy & Cozy Home Away from Home!**This charming three-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bathroom house features a spacious yard perfect for adults to unwind while the kids enjoy playtime. In the evenings, gather around the large fire pit for s'mores or kick back and relax after a wonderful day at the beach!The home is equipped with everything you need for a comfortable stay, including central air conditioning, forced gas heating, a washer/dryer, a dishwasher, high-speed Wi-Fi, and YouTube TV. The fully stocked kitchen caters to all your cooking needs, or you can fire up the Weber Genesis gas grill for a delicious steak.Conveniently located just steps from the marina, beach, shops, ice cream parlors, and restaurants, you can easily walk to the popular Bentwood and Stray Dog restaurants, as well as Oink’s Ice Cream. Downtown New Buffalo is only a 10-minute walk or a quick 1-minute drive away, where you'll find Barneys Market (liquor and grocery), charming boutiques, and more dining options.If you're looking for a night out, the local casino offers a shuttle service that picks up at the Marina Grand Hotel, located just half a block away. Enjoy the public beach and park, only a short 10-15 minute walk from your doorstep.With just a short drive, explore Redamaks (open in the summer), Union Pier shops, local breweries and wineries, and the stunning Indiana and Warren Dunes, along with all the exciting activities that Harbor Country has to offer.**Welcome to New Buffalo! We can't wait to host you!**About pets:No pets allowed.About checkOut:Check out before 11:00 AM.About children:Children allowed: ages 0-17.A pack n play and high chair are available for use.About checkIn:Check in after 3:00 PM.About smoking:Smoking is not permitted.About minBookingAge:Minimum age to rent: 25.About events:No events allowed.
Outstanding
20 reviews
10/10
Check availability
65
Hotels in New Buffalo
Discover the charm of downtown New Buffalo in this elegant 2-bedroom, 2-bath condo that seamlessly blends luxury with convenience. Located just steps from lively Main Street, this refined getaway features upscale details and breathtaking marina views.Inside, the open layout boasts gleaming hardwood floors, a warm gas fireplace, and stylish granite countertops. The chef’s kitchen, equipped with premium stainless steel appliances, is ideal for crafting gourmet meals. The serene master suite includes a queen-size bed and a private en suite bathroom, while the second bedroom offers two queen-size beds, comfortably accommodating up to six guests—perfect for families or groups.Unwind on your private first-floor balcony with views of the marina, or enjoy gatherings on the rooftop patio with stunning sunset views (reservation required).Situated in a secure gated community, the condo offers in-unit laundry, a modern fitness center, and indoor and outdoor pools. Conveniently near the New Buffalo Amtrak station, it provides easy access to Chicago, Detroit, and more. Additionally, it’s only a 45-minute drive to Notre Dame football games, making it a great choice for sports enthusiasts.With boutique shopping, delectable dining, and the scenic Lake Michigan shoreline all within walking distance, this condo is the ultimate retreat. Reserve your stay today and experience the best of lakeside living!About pets:No pets allowed.About checkOut:Check out before 11:00 AM.About children:Children allowed: ages 0-17.About customRules:• Avoid tracking sand into the apartment, especially into shower drains, to prevent plumbing issues..• Flush only toilet paper. Do not flush cosmetic products, wipes, or tissues as they can cause blockages.,• Keep noise levels down and clean shared amenities. • Keep common areas free of personal belongings and clutter..About checkIn:Check in after 4:30 PM.About smoking:Smoking is not permitted.About events:No events allowed.
Outstanding
19 reviews
10/10
Check availability
46
Hotels in New Buffalo
Part of the beautiful Merchant Street Cottages in New Buffalo, MI, there’s no need to look any further for your getaway accommodations! We are one of the newest cottages in town! More photos @cottageonwhidbeyJust 2 blocks from downtown New Buffalo and a 10 minute walk to the best beach in Michigan, this roughly 2,700 sq. ft. Cottage was smartly designed for vacations of just about any size group. Situated at the end of a private lane and with no street in front of the house, you’re on your own here! 4 bedrooms (3 queens, 2 twins, queen sleeper sofa & queen air mattress) and 3.5 baths spread across 3 floors with 2 separate living areas, a rear screened-in patio and covered front porch, pool table, two large TVs with streaming cable, Netflix, Amazon Prime, etc,, natural gas grill and bikes just about sums it up…Not to mention a secret loft stocked with books and games for the kiddos (we also have about ALL the baby items you'll need, so no need to pack much)! Oh - And don’t forget the heated community pool exclusively for Merchant Street Cottage guests just three houses down from our front door! The pool is typically open mid-May through end of September!The vibe throughout the cottage is that of a modern farmhouse, giving you the feel of a relaxing getaway with all the comforts of home. Cook a meal in the gourmet kitchen and enjoy it at the custom-made 8-person farmhouse dining table surrounded by windows overlooking beautiful landscaping & flagstone patio w/cafe lights! Flip on the gas fireplace, sync your phone to the Bluetooth speaker to set the soundtrack of your stay and pour yourself a glass of your favorite beverage to unwind. Or head downstairs to the finished basement to liven it up with a game of pool, settle in for a movie on the 65” flatscreen or hang out in the lounge area by the pool table and play some cards or one of our many modern board games.Want to be outside? Of course you do! Just head out to one of the two covered porches that offer comfortable settings with overhead fans to keep everyone cool on those hot summer days. The rear screened-in porch is a perfect spot for escaping the ‘skeeters, opening out to a flagstone patio where you can fire up the natural gas barbecue and gather around the picnic table. The front porch is a great spot for the whole family, as this quiet end lot offers up a private setting so you can enjoy a cup of coffee from the coffee bar while the kids burn off some energy in the yard, which blends into a large community garden area. Grab our cruiser bicycles from the garage to pedal to town or the beach, down Marquette Street to scope out the lakefront mansions or check out the natural beauty of Harbor Country on one of the self-guided bike tours of the Backroad Bikeways.Don’t fret - The house is fully equipped for your social media, cable, Netflixing and general web surfing needs. Two Smart TVs will ensure that you’re able to unwind and watch some tube, if that’s what you want! TVs are dialed in to provide everyone with streaming Xfinity cable, Netflix, Amazon Prime, Hulu and a plethora of other TV apps.Quite honestly, we began to lay out the “Things to Do” portion of this listing and realized the picture we were trying to illustrate is already perfectly detailed at http://newbuffaloexplored.com. Go there - Trust us, it’s unlike any other Harbor Country portrayal out there and will get the juices flowing for your trip planning purposes.The bottom line is that we’re two and a half blocks from the heart of New Buffalo (shopping, wine tasting, dining, casino shuttle, nightlife, ice cream, farmers' market and more), a 10-minute walk to the beach and a short trip to anywhere and anything you want to do on your trip to Harbor Country!If you’re from Chicago, go ahead and skip this next paragraph, but the rest of you will be excited to know that in just over an hour you can be downtown Chicago! Take a quick walk to the Amtrak station in the center of town and hop on the train, which drops you off at Union Station and returns to New Buffalo a few times each day. Or for more frequent train departures to the city, check out the South Shore Line from one of many stops in the surrounding cities (ex, Michigan City). About 20 years ago we accidentally stumbled upon New Buffalo and fell in love with the town. Over the years we keep coming back, making countless memories over numerous stays. We were able to turn our love for the area into a passion project, and now we can’t wait to share our Cottage with you!About pets:No pets allowed.Absolutely no pets in or around the Cottage!.About checkOut:Check out before 10:00 AM.About children:Children allowed: ages 0-17.About customRules:Guests are provided our Homeowner's Association Guest Rules and are expected to review and abide by them, along with our Reservation Agreement..This is a quiet family community and therefore does not suit any loud music or party type atmospheres. Especially, outdoor drinking games.,There are homeowners who do not rent and spend a lot of time at their homes and tend to "police" any behavior that does not fit the neighborhood rules.About checkIn:Check in after 4:00 PM.About smoking:Smoking is not permitted.No smoking in the house or on screened-in patio.About events:No events allowed.No bachelor or bachelorette parties, thanks!.
Outstanding
44 reviews
10/10
Check availability
37
Hotels in New Buffalo
Fall/Winter special: Reserve 2 nights get 3rd night free. Heated pool opens May 15!Welcome to Harbor country. Our area is home to the magnificent Lake Michigan coastal towns, fantastic restaurants, national parks, breweries and wineries. This sprawling five bedroom, 2-1/2 bathroom, colonial home built in 1887 is the perfect place for you and your family or group of friends. Enter this vintage home from either of the two front porches, both are ideal for your morning coffee or evening glass of wine, and you will be amazed at what you see. The first floor includes a large king bedroom with smart tv and cedar closet. Next is our full bathroom with tub/shower. Our dining room has seating for 6 and next to it is our cozy living room that has comfortable seating, a smart tv with cable and a view to our courtyard and pool. Next there is a large gourmet kitchen that includes an island with seating for 6 and a breakfast nook that can accommodate 7. This luxury, state-of-the art, spacious kitchen is truly a show piece and a great place to gather. A truly gourmet kitchen with top notch appliances lots of cabinets and counter space. Virtually everything you need has been thought of. Also, a fantastic server/bar cart and a Samsung, The Frame 55" tv with cable. Just off the kitchen is a large laundry room and powder room. On the second floor you will find 4 bedrooms and bathroom. The first bedroom is beyond large and includes 3 twin beds, one king bed, a full sleeper sofa and smart tv, popular place for kids to hang out in. Second bedroom has a king bed and includes a desk and large closet, third bedroom is a queen and the last bedroom has two twin beds. The bathroom includes a tiled, walk-in shower which is next to a large linen closet filled with towels.Our courtyard is truly a centerpiece for all you need. Dive into our 15x32 saltwater heated pool with tanning shelf, enjoy our 8-10 person jacuzzi. You also might want to relax by the fire-pit in one of our 8 Adirondack chairs with a glass of a local wine or micro-brew. There is also plenty of space for outdoor games both inside the yard as well in our oversized side lot. This open concept house plan allows for plenty of room for the kids to be entertained while you sit back, relax and enjoy Pure Michigan. This location is ideal in so many ways- we are just a couple blocks to Brewster's Italian or waterside fine dining at Bentwood Tavern or The Terrace Room. From our home you'll enjoy the very short walk to downtown New Buffalo and the beach. Also we are just an hour away from Chicago by car or Amtrak, you'll soon be steps away to all the conveniences of Harbor Country. Hop on a shuttle to Four Winds Casino, or a short drive to Blue Chip Casino and the Outlet Mall. A great place to take walks to town or the beach as well as bike riding. Tour the wineries and micro-breweries and so much more. Whether you are planning an all-adult trip or a family getaway this home sleeps 14 comfortably and is the perfect compliment to any of your planned activities. For your information the local ordinance has quiet hours at 10pm and we ask that our guests respect that as we live on a quiet residential block. For that reason we do not allow bachelor or bachelorette parties.Also we have added an exterior camera to monitor the exterior of our home for liability reasons for our insurance. It is located at the side of driveway. There are absolutely no cameras located inside the house or facing the pool. Pool will be closed mid Sept till mid May - hot tub is open year round. There is a house guide in a binder at the property with all the information you will need.Also, City of New Buffalo passed an ordinance, effective 6/14/21, that limits parking to 4 cars maximum, limits number of guests to 14, enforces the noise ordinance and requires a Reservation Summary. That form requests the full name and date of birth for the main contact, full name and age of each guest, and make, model and license plate number (including State) for each car that will be on the property. That form needs to be in the city’s hand no less than 24 hours before reservation. That form will be sent to you in a fillable format but if you would rather send me the information, I can fill it out for you. Thank you for your cooperation.About pets:No pets allowed.Strictly enforced.About checkOut:Check out before 10:00 AM.About children:Children allowed: ages 0-17.Child friendly with lots of amenities.About checkIn:Check in after 4:00 PM.About smoking:Smoking is not permitted.Smoking/vaping is forbidden-$200 will be charged.About minBookingAge:Minimum age to rent: 25.About events:No events allowed.If complaint is made renter’s responsible for fees.
Outstanding
17 reviews
10/10
Check availability
11
Hotels in New Buffalo
A spacious beach getaway in the heart of down town New Buffalo and a short walk to beach. Start the day with the view from the rooftop deck before hitting the private Dunescape pool!Just over an hour from Chicago whether by car or train - the train station is just steps from Beach Retreat. Newly Constructed townhome in the heart of New Buffalo offers three levels of living space with a rooftop terrace, numerous decks, and a screened in area. With three bedrooms, three bathrooms, and ample living space this home is great for entertaining. With an onsite swimming pool this is perfect for families or a small group of friends looking to escape for a weekend and enjoy all Harbor Country has to offer.The rooftop affords breathtaking views of the lake and downtown. The all seasons room has just been redone and is the perfect spot to relax. This property offers something for everyone of all ages & is not to be missed!The living room is equipped with a ROKU smart HDTV and opens up to the 3 seasons room. Bedroom 3 also has a ROKU smart HDTV with ample programming.Each bedroom has outdoor deck in addition to the rooftoop deck & the master has a jacuzzi tub. Enjoy the chef's kitchen and brand new outdoor Weber grill with the bounty of local and organic ingredients that SW Michigan has to offer.Close by you also have FourWinds Casino, various wineries, Journeyman Distillery, Greenbush Brewery, Bentwood Tavern & The Terrace Room - ideal for a foodie getaway. Michigan City (just 15 minutes away), you can visit the Blue Chip Casino, Zoo, and the Lighthouse Place Premium outlet Mall with over 120 outlet stores just waiting for you. For those Notre Dame fans, New Buffalo is a convenient base for attending the game.Please note that during summer season we do week long bookings only Friday through Friday and the pool is open only for summer season About pets:Pets allowed: dogs less than 50 lbs per pet (limit 2 pets total).About checkOut:Check out before 11:00 AM.About children:Children allowed: ages 0-17.About customRules:Beach towels are not provide so please bring your own. Glass is not allowed at the pool..About checkIn:Check in after 4:00 PM.About smoking:Smoking is not permitted.About minBookingAge:Minimum age to rent: 21.About events:No events allowed.
Outstanding
13 reviews
9.8/10
Check availability
14
Hotels in New Buffalo
Lilly's Beach and Pool Pad is one of those we must be at the beach homes. Main level of home totally renovated 2023 including all new cabinets, appliances and flooring. Located in the heart of New Buffalo, this lovely home sits on a 1/2 acre fenced lot with a 18x36 inground Heated Pool that glistens in the backyard. This home is great for entertaining with an open concept that flows out to the pool area. Come enjoy Lake Michigan at its best. Association Beach access steps from the home. This Five Bedroom Three bath home sits two homes from Lake Michigan. This is a private beach that is only shared with Sunset Shores residents. The beach is currently small but great to jump in the lake or watch sunsets. The public beach which is large and sandy is within walking distance. You are also a short walk to restaurants, Marina and the shops of New Buffalo.The owner has not missed a beat on putting Lilly's Beach Pad together. There is an open floor plan on the main level of this tri-level home. It is very conducive to entertaining inside and outside with two sets of sliding glass doors that lead from the kitchen/dining are to the pool and patio area. This home has two living areas one up and one down, a perfect wind down after a long day of the beach and swimming. There are three bedrooms upstairs, one on the main level and one downstairs. There are three bathrooms one on the main level, one upper and one lower. The home has wireless internet, gas grill, firepit and many other amenities. This home is great for one large family or two smaller families. I don't know if a vacation gets better then this in Harbor Country, so come join us and make lasting family memories. Or take a wine tour to one of the local wineries and breweries. If you are a large group the home next door is available to rent. It is listing 20296 and sleeps 14. Keywords: Beach Area, Private Beach, Close to beach, house, cottage, New Buffalo, Harbor Country, Lake Michigan, Pool, Heated Pool, Private Pool, Close to Marina, close to town, wineries, breweries, dispensariesAbout pets:Pets allowed: dogs (limit 2 total).Each pet is $200 per pet/per stay..About checkOut:Check out before 11:00 AM.About children:Children allowed: ages 0-17.About checkIn:Check in after 5:00 PM.About smoking:Smoking is not permitted.About minBookingAge:Minimum age to rent: 21.About events:No events allowed.
Great
9 reviews
9.2/10
Check availability
25
Hotels in New Buffalo
You are walking distance to downtown, restaurants & the beach. New Buffalo has a well known wine trail to enjoy with some great hiking. Take a dip in our steamy hot tub or roast marshmallows in our fire pit! Rain in the forecast...no worries we have plenty of board games or cozy up on the couch and read a good book. About pets:No pets allowed.About checkOut:Check out before 10:00 AM.About children:Children allowed: ages 0-17.About checkIn:Check in after 4:00 PM.About smoking:Smoking is not permitted.About minBookingAge:Minimum age to rent: 21.About events:No events allowed.
Outstanding
52 reviews
10/10
Check availability
33
Hotels in New Buffalo
With a stay at this apartment in New Buffalo (Downtown New Buffalo), you'll be within a 5-minute drive of Lake Michigan and New Buffalo Public Beach. This apartment is 11.6 mi (18.7 km) from Indiana Dunes National Park and 3.3 mi (5.4 km) from Four Winds Casino New Buffalo. Take advantage of recreation opportunities such as an outdoor pool, or other amenities including complimentary wireless internet access and an arcade/game room. Free self parking is available onsite. Make yourself comfortable in this air-conditioned apartment, which features a fireplace and a flat-screen TV. There's a private balcony. A kitchen is outfitted with an oven, a stovetop, and a microwave. Conveniences include a ceiling fan and an iron/ironing board.
Outstanding
9.8/10
Check availability
See More 3-Star Hotels in New Buffalo

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does a 3 star hotel cost in New Buffalo?

For 3 star hotels in New Buffalo, the average price on weekdays is PLN 674, the average price on weekends (Friday–Saturday) is PLN 1,063.

What are the best 3 star hotels with pools in New Buffalo?

There are many 3 star hotels in New Buffalo with swimming pool. Holiday Inn Express & Suites NEW BUFFALO, MI by IHG (price from PLN 446) is very popular.

Which 3 star hotels in New Buffalo have fitness centre?

Which 3 star hotels in New Buffalo offer great breakfasts?

Holiday Inn Express & Suites NEW BUFFALO, MI by IHG (price from PLN 446) provides delicious breakfast to start your day.

What are the best 3 star hotels in New Buffalo with free Wi-Fi?

What are the best deals for 3 star hotels in New Buffalo?

Trip.com offers promotions and deals for 3 star hotels. You can visit the promotions page to find out what offers are available on Trip.com.

Hotel Info for Tourists

Number of Reviews 226
Total Properties11
Weekday Avg. PricePLN 674
Weekend Avg. PricePLN 1,063