Top-Rated Hotels in Hampton Bays with Prices and Guest Reviews

Find popular Hampton Bays hotels frequently selected by travellers for business, leisure and family stays.

Hamptons Vacation Inn

Hamptons Vacation Inn

📍 177 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays
★★★ 8.9 (86 reviews)

The Hampton Maid

The Hampton Maid

📍 259 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays
★★ 9.2 (100 reviews)

Hampton Bays Hotel on Main

Hampton Bays Hotel on Main

📍 2 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays
★★ 7.4 (51 reviews)

"Excellent"

Ocean View Terrace

Ocean View Terrace

📍 285 East Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays
★★ 8.8 (41 reviews)

"Booked 2 nights stay here (impromptu) when visiting NYC. Brilliant location if you're planning to drive round the Hamptons. Very clean, comfortable, all amenities you need, friendly staff. Thoroughly enjoyed our stay.Highly recommend."

Canoe Place Inn & Cottages

Canoe Place Inn & Cottages

📍 239 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays
★★★★ 9.5 (67 reviews)

"My husband and I had lunch in their outdoor Cafe and Bar twice. We found the menu somewhat limited but the food was good. The Bloody Mary was excellent. The service was dreadful though. The first and second time we went. You’d think a very special place like this would address this problem! Also did not like the decor but that’s just my opinion!"

The Penny Lane

The Penny Lane

📍 16 Penny Lane, Hampton Bays
★★ 9.1 (49 reviews)

"Had such a lovely stay at Penny Lane Hotel. The canal views with the Adirondack chairs were beautiful — the perfect place to enjoy coffee in the morning or watch the sunset. The room was spotless, modern, cozy, and I loved how each one feels like its own little cottage with a private porch. The main house also has a nice sitting area with coffee and continental breakfast in the morning. The manager was incredibly attentive and responsive via text, which made the stay even better. Such a relaxing and welcoming place — I would definitely stay again."

Bayview Resort

Bayview Resort

📍 53 W Tiana Road, Hampton Bays
★★★ 8.6 (79 reviews)

Bay Watch Hotel and Marina

Bay Watch Hotel and Marina

📍 72 Foster Avenue, Hampton Bays
★★★ 8.4 (40 reviews)

"My wife and I stayed there during August 2025 for a night. All around, really positive. Great bang for your buck and deliciously placed near plenty of public and quit beaches in a quaint area. Debbie and Larry are courteous and generous and very professional. Would love to come here again. Just keep in mind, Montauk Point is still over an hour away and getting further by the year (nothing to do with climate change, just traffic :). Great pool, clean rooms, charming and relaxing!"

Hamptons Waterfront- On A Sandy Beach- Relax & GetawaySH)

Hamptons Waterfront- On A Sandy Beach- Relax & GetawaySH)

📍 Hampton Bays
★★★ 10 (5 reviews)

Compare Hampton Bays Hotels by Cleanliness, Location and Service from real customers

8.5
Excellent community rating
Real & verified guest reviews from all over the world
G

Guest User

Business traveler
Hampton Bays Hotel on Main ★★
"Great host !!"
★★★★★
2026-05-05
N

NorthStar45678610204

Other
Ocean View Terrace ★★
"Seems to be family run, very nice staff Comfortable & attractive rooms, quiet (no loud noise in the vicinity) Has a pool, beach is open to hotel guests & is accross the street Ocean view from the pool & the rooms overlooking the pool Convenient location"
★★★★★
2024-08-20
G

Guest User

Family
Canoe Place Inn & Cottages ★★★★
"We will not be returning. While the rooms are cute, the restaurant is terrible - overpriced and tiny menu + they force you into one dining area so the entire time we stayed we could only eat outside - we never got to enjoy the indoor dining room. The lobby doesn't exist - it's just a room with a couple desks in it. The pool area feels like an apartment building pool - bad chaise lounges and pretty bleak. No pool service either unless you walk up to the restaurant bar outside the pool. As is, you have no view and you are on busy roads with a lot of noise! Plus...you are not really in the hamptons - you are on the outskirt so prepare to do a lot of driving if you stay here. All and all, not a great experience. One bright spot is the staff - they were incredible."
★★☆☆☆
2026-06-12
n

nmquattr

Traveling with friends
The Penny Lane ★★
"My friends and I had the best time at The Penny Lane for my bachelorette party! The decor was so cute and chic. The beds are ridiculously comfy. The 3-bd house is set up perfectly for families or friend groups. The staff was incredibly friendly and helpful. Will definitely be back!"
★★★★★
2026-04-28
G

Guest User

Other
Bay Watch Hotel and Marina ★★★
"My friend and I wanted to visit the Hamptons for a long weekend this summer. It was a last minute trip, and I wasn't expecting to find a lot of availability. But Bay Watch Hotel and Marina came to the rescue. Our standard room was ready when we arrived - was nice and air conditioned and had a full kitchenette with everything we might need (including microwave and mini-fridge). The staff was friendly and helpful, and always around if we needed something. The pool was amazing! I was expecting it to be crowded, considering it was peak time in the summer, but it was quiet and peaceful. The hotel room and grounds were clean and well-kept. I especially liked the string lights all around at night. Parking was plentiful and location was ideal, right near the beaches and not far from Southhampton. The whole experience was relaxing and hassle-free - exactly what we needed. I will be back!"
★★★★★
2023-07-23
G

Guest User

Other
Hampton Ocean Resort ★★
"What a hidden gem on the ocean! The beach at Hampton Ocean Resort was spectacular, and our family made memories, with weekend smores on the beach and a steel drummer! The staff was friendly and efficient, and the rooms clean and comfortable. It's not plush, but it sure is fantastic!"
★★★★★
2024-08-05

Useful Information for Your Trip to Hampton Bays

Power Plug & Voltage

120V/Type A/B

💵

Exchange Rate

1 AED ≈ 0.27 USD

💳

Local Payment

Cards/ApplePay/Cash

📱

Connectivity

Verizon/AT&T/T-Mobile

🌡️

Current Weather

Cloudy

More Hampton Bays hotel info

Data type

Details

Number of Reviews

623

Total Properties

31

Weekday Avg. Price

AED 1,874

Weekend Avg. Price

AED 2,083

Trending hotel

Hamptons Vacation Inn

Hampton Bays hotel FAQs

Disclaimer: This article has been provided by an individual contributor or third party platform. If there is any discrepancy regarding the copyright, please contact us directly and we will delete the content immediately.