Top-Rated Hotels in Islay with Prices and Guest Reviews

Find popular Islay hotels frequently selected by travellers for business, leisure and family stays.

Port Charlotte Youth Hostel
9.4 (19 reviews)

Port Charlotte Youth Hostel ★★★

📍 Main St, Islay

"This was one of the very best SYHA hostels that I've visited. The people running it were very hospitable and concerned for their visitors. In many ways you could see how thoughtful they had been to make it a good and interesting experience for all. The kitchen, common room, showers, drying room etc were all excellent. I recommend it heartily."

Another Place - the Machrie
9.2 (68 reviews)

Another Place - the Machrie ★★★★

📍 Machrie Hotel, Islay

"We enjoyed the privacy as it was at least a km away from the main road. A very nice hideaway if you want to get away from the bustling town. One thing though, please ensure you have your own car/transport covered as public transportation on Islay is not as convenient versus a normal city. Overall, a great place to stay! We’ll be back!"

Port Charlotte Hotel
9.2 (59 reviews)

Port Charlotte Hotel ★★★★

📍 Main St, Islay

"This was a fantastic place to stay for our multi-day whiskey tasting tour on Islay. It is located on the water and offers beautiful views of the bay. There's a place to swim if you are brave enough. The rooms are very comfortable, good-sized and well appointed. The staff was incredibly welcoming and helpful with a few small requests -- i.e. packing tape to box up our whiskey! We chose the hotel as it had a restaurant on-property--and were glad we did. We ate both our dinners and breakfasts at the hotel. The food and service were outstanding and they have a fantastic wine list."

Glenegedale House
9.9 (58 reviews)

Glenegedale House ★★★★★

📍 Glenegedale House, Glenegedale Isle of, Islay

"Two couples do it. Both are good people. Husband is serious and sincere, wife is kind and kind. It's a short walk from the airport and the bus stop is right in front of you, so the convenience is good and the scenery is perfect."

Islay House
8.0 (50 reviews)

Islay House ★★★

📍 House, Bridgend, Islay

"We spent our final evening in Islay here. Has to be one of the nicest settings on Islay. The owners try really hard to make guests feel at home and the rooms are comfortable."

The Bowmore House Bed and Breakfast
10 (41 reviews)

The Bowmore House Bed and Breakfast ★★★★

📍 Shore St, Islay, Bowmore

"This is my third stay at Bowmore House, my first being ten years ago. The room was excellent and comfortable, with a superb bathroom and a powerful shower. The cleanliness and order were impeccable. I highly recommend the full Scottish breakfast, which includes tattie scones and haggis. Andrew, the proprietor, provided a complimentary dram to each guest."

Beautiful 10 person modern bungalow in Bruichladdich with stunning views
9.6 (67 reviews)

Beautiful 10 person modern bungalow in Bruichladdich with stunning views ★★★★

📍 Bruichladdich

The Island Bear B&B
9.6 (47 reviews)

The Island Bear B&B ★★★

📍 SHORE STREET, Bowmore

Unique House in an Idyllic Situation on a Beach
10 (14 reviews)

Unique House in an Idyllic Situation on a Beach ★★★

📍 Traigh Bheag East, Distillery Road, Port Ellen

See All Hotels in Islay

Compare Islay Hotels by Cleanliness, Location and Service from real customers

9.6
Excellent community rating
Real & verified guest reviews from all over the world
R

Ruth C

Solo traveler
Port Charlotte Youth Hostel ★★★
"Having never stayed in a youth hostel before and being a single middle aged woman, I was a little apprehensive. I'd booked 2 nights accommodation so I could be near to my friends who were in the adjacent hotel. I was so well looked after by the couple who run the hostel that I soon felt very at ease. My room was comfortable and a decent size with 2 single beds and a sink. All bed linen and one towel are provided. The showers and ladies toilets were just opposite my room so not being ensuite wasn't an issue. Breakfast (paid for separately) was more than sufficient, help yourself to freshly made coffee, toast, yoghurt, fruit, cereals. Milk and coffee also avaliable free of charge if you want to make a drink late at night. The facilities are excellent although I have nothing to compare them with. A very large well-equipped kitchen and dining room and a separate sitting room. All very clean. Other quests while I was there were all adults so I didn't feel an odd one out amongst a lot of youths as I had expected. What a fantastic location too, right on the beach."
★★★★★
2023-09-25
t

CN tjqm

Business traveler
Another Place - the Machrie ★★★★
"This hotel is the best hotel on Islay. If you like to play golf, you must not miss it here. The restaurant is great and the view is beautiful. The room was very clean and comfortable"
★★★★★
2023-10-04
m

mysteriousdonkey

Family
Port Charlotte Hotel ★★★★
"Family dinner on a Tuesday evening. Had visited on a couple of previous occasions when visiting Islay and it seems that service has gone downhill slightly recently. Food was excellent as normal. No qualms about that whatsoever. Service was the issue. Seated in the restaurant and after menus were handed out and after a short while before any drinks orders were taken, one of the waitresses started collecting wine glasses off the table. Had to tell her that we were going to be ordering wine and the glasses were replaced. The main waiter in the restaurant was very softly spoken and so was difficult to understand at times. Seemed awkward when serving. I honestly think the evening was missing Lorna - the times we were there before she was managing the restaurant. When I asked at the end if Lorna still worked here, got a very vague reply that was "sometimes". The Lorna equivalent that evening (didn't get her name, assume she would be the restaurant manager for the evening) made one appearance at the start, seemed quite brusque and wasn't seen again throughout the evening. Total contrast to previous experience."
★★★★★
2024-09-20
G

JP Guest User

Couple
Glenegedale House ★★★★★
"Two couples do it. Both are good people. Husband is serious and sincere, wife is kind and kind. It's a short walk from the airport and the bus stop is right in front of you, so the convenience is good and the scenery is perfect."
★★★★★
2026-03-28
G

Guest User

Other
Islay House ★★★
"Absolutely LOVED this place - yes it could do with a bit of updating but from what I gather, it's in the works. The manager John (Joao?) was so accommodating and professional and our room and bathroom were GORGEOUS. Cannot wait to come back in the future. Thanks for a marvellous stay! (Can't seem to add photos for some reason but took loads)"
★★★★★
2026-04-10
G

Guest User

Other
The Bowmore House Bed and Breakfast ★★★★
"We stayed at Bowmore House for 3 nights as part of the Scottish Routes Islay whiskey tour. The room was lovely and very comfortable with incredible views across the loch. The breakfast was really good, very informal, very comfortable. The hosts were lovely, very friendly and more than willing to help with any requests; they even invited us to a breakfast dram in the mornings! A really enjoyable stop, highly recommended"
★★★★★
2025-07-03

Useful Information for Your Trip to Islay

⚡

Power Plug & Voltage

230V/Type G

💵

Exchange Rate

GBP

💳

Local Payment

Cards/ApplePay/Cash

📱

Connectivity

EE/Vodafone/O2/Three

🌡️

Current Weather

Cloudy

More Islay hotel info

Data type

Details

Number of Reviews

518

Total Properties

16

Weekday Avg. Price

AED 1,105

Weekend Avg. Price

AED 1,135

Trending hotel

Glenegedale House

Islay hotel FAQs

  • What are the best places to stay in Islay?

    Some top places to stay in Islay are near popular attractions like Islay North & West Parish: St Kiaran's Church—so you can quickly get to top landmarks and amenities you need.

  • What is the average price of a hotel in Islay for this weekend?

    According to Trip.com’s latest 12-month data, 3-star hotels in Islay have an average price of AED 840 per night this weekend. For 4-star hotels, the average rate is AED 1,474 per night. If you’re seeking luxury, 5-star hotels in Islay typically cost AED 1,165 per night this weekend.

  • How much do hotels in Islay typically cost on weekdays?

    Based on Trip.com’s latest 12-month data, the average nightly rate for 3-star hotels in Islay on weekdays is AED 835. For 4-star hotels, the average cost is around AED 1,369 per night. For a luxury stay, 5-star hotels in Islay generally have an average price of AED 1,118 per night on weekdays.

  • What hotels in Islay offer an especially good breakfast?

    Begin your day with a tasty and satisfying breakfast! Glenegedale House (price from AED 1,529), Another Place - the Machrie (price from AED 1,687) and Port Charlotte Hotel (price from AED 1,426) provide the best breakfast to start your day.

  • Which hotels in Islay provide fitness facilities?

    Another Place - the Machrie (price from AED 1,687) offers fitness facilities to keep you active during your stay. Stay on track with your fitness goals while on the go!

  • What are the best hotels with a spa in Islay?

    A spa hotel can make your trip more enjoyable with relaxing amenities. Another Place - the Machrie (price from AED 1,687) is one of the best hotels with a spa in the area.

  • What are the best hotels in Islay near Islay North & West Parish: St Kiaran's Church?

    Some standout hotels in Islay close to Islay North & West Parish: St Kiaran's Church include Port Charlotte Youth Hostel (price from AED 163), Glenegedale House (price from AED 1,529) and Islay House (price from AED 504), all within easy walking or transit distance of Islay North & West Parish: St Kiaran's Church, perfect for travelers wanting to explore the landmark and its surroundings.

  • How to get good deals on hotels in Islay?

    Find the best hotel deals and promotions on Trip.com, available year-round for both first-time and loyal users. Please check the promotions page to see what promotions are available now on Trip.com.

Disclaimer: This article has been provided by an individual contributor or third party platform. If there is any discrepancy regarding the copyright, please contact us directly and we will delete the content immediately.