Top-Rated Hotels in Islamorada with Prices and Guest Reviews

Find popular Islamorada hotels frequently selected by travellers for business, leisure and family stays.

Cheeca Lodge & Spa
9.1 (112 reviews)

Cheeca Lodge & Spa ★★★★★

📍 81801 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

"1. Can’t watch the sunset 2. 3,000 per night is expensive and there is no breakfast. 3. The sound insulation effect of the house is poor, like a domestic construction site house"

The Islands of Islamorada
9.4 (46 reviews)

The Islands of Islamorada ★★★★

📍 82779 Old Highway, Islamorada

"Great experience at this hotel. You can tell when a hotelier pays attention to customer reviews and comments. Things may happen, and excellent customer service means making things right and keeping the customer experience #1. My family of 3 (including a 13 year old) had a great time. The room was spacious, our balcony had a great view of the ocean and the resort staff were friendly & helpful. What more can you ask for!"

Pines & Palms Resort
9.2 (101 reviews)

Pines & Palms Resort ★★★

📍 80401 Old Hwy, Islamorada

"The hotel is still good, this room type needs to take the stairs to carry luggage and the price is set to be 50% off on the day."

La Jolla Resort
9.0 (102 reviews)

La Jolla Resort ★★

📍 82216 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

"The room was ok. The bathroom ceiling was very low and small shower. But the location is great by the water. Very expensive for what it was."

Breezy Palms Resort
8.4 (101 reviews)

Breezy Palms Resort ★★

📍 80015 U.S. Rte 1, Islamorada

"We had an amazing relaxing time at Breezy Palms resort!!! We stayed in a 1st floor ocean front apartment that was recently updated, very clean and had a great view of the ocean. Nice to have the full kitchen-used every day. Bathroom was just right and had great shower! Bed was comfortable and great sheets!Screened lanai was perfect. Pool was wonderful, clean and warmer than the ocean! There is nice small beach with sand here. We didn’t get a chance to use the outdoor BBQs, but they looked well maintained, clean, and had everything for grilling. Office staff was friendly and helpful. Fully stocked on site store with bait, snacks, clothing, bottled soft drinks, Blue Bunny ice cream treats, and toiletries. Great maintenance throughout the resort. Although on Route 1, we didn’t hear the highway - lots of roosters and birds chirping. Iguanas were cool to see every day. They have a great dock to fish off of and we did fish for the last 3 days (got a 3 day salt water shore fishing license from nearby bait & tackle store) off the concrete dock and caught a grunt, pinfish, & 28” tarpon - all released. This location was great for seeing all of the keys because it’s a mile marker 80. Walking to nearby restaurants, marina and bridge to see sunset was within 1/4 mile - we could have used the bicycles, but didn’t bring the right footwear for biking. Breezy Palms resort was awesome!! Definitely a place for everyone - couples, families & solo travelers."

Islander Resort
9.2 (103 reviews)

Islander Resort ★★★★

📍 82100 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

"Perfect"

Amara Cay Resort
8.5 (101 reviews)

Amara Cay Resort ★★★★

📍 80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

"I used to love this place but in this visit I saw the hotel hallways dirty and smelling. The beds were really uncomfortable, I suppose they are old because I felt the the springs when I laid down on the bed. The amenities are absolutely amazing, the pool was really clean and everything outside was in perfect condition. The food from the restaurant was delicious."

Coconut Cove Resort & Marina
9.0 (100 reviews)

Coconut Cove Resort & Marina ★★

📍 84801 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Bayside Villas by Islander Resort
8.9 (87 reviews)

Bayside Villas by Islander Resort ★★★

📍 81450 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Compare Islamorada Hotels by Cleanliness, Location and Service from real customers

8.9
Excellent community rating
Real & verified guest reviews from all over the world
G

XX Guest User

Family
Cheeca Lodge & Spa ★★★★★
"Cheeca Lodge is the premier place to stay in Islamorada for awesome rooms and amenities. Food is excellent and the staff is some of the best I've ever encountered. Love this place and will stay again."
★★★★★
2026-03-16
G

Guest User

Other
The Islands of Islamorada ★★★★
"Our stay at Isla Morada Resort was excellent—easily one of the top places to stay in the Keys, and it’s clear why it’s so highly rated. The property itself is stunning. The grounds are lush, meticulously maintained, and feel like a private tropical retreat. Every detail—from the landscaping to the layout—creates a sense of calm and exclusivity. The buildings are relatively new, and it shows: everything feels modern, clean, and thoughtfully designed. We stayed in an Ocean Suite on the second floor, and the space was impressive—easily around 1,000 square feet. The layout was functional and comfortable, with a large bedroom, a spacious bathroom with dual sinks and a generous shower (hot water almost instantly), and a balcony overlooking the tiki bar, pool, and ocean. Sitting out there in the evening with the breeze and sunset was a highlight. The amenities are well done without being overbearing. Multiple pools give you options—one more family-oriented near the tiki bar, and another quieter pool that felt almost private during our stay. There’s also a scenic walking path, pickleball courts, a gym, and even covered areas with games for when the weather turns. Bikes and fishing gear are available, and staff are around if you need anything—but otherwise, they let you enjoy the property without constant upselling. Service was excellent and accommodating. Requests for extra towels and daily sheet changes were handled promptly without issue. A couple minor drawbacks: parking can be tight, especially near the Ocean Suites, and while food can be ordered and delivered anywhere on the property, there’s no true on-site sit-down restaurant—particularly noticeable at breakfast. Also, for a property at this level, the in-room coffee setup feels like an afterthought and could be upgraded. That said, these are small critiques in an otherwise outstanding stay. The overall experience is peaceful, polished, and thoughtfully executed."
★★★★★
2026-04-16
G

CN Guest User

Couple
Pines & Palms Resort ★★★
"The hotel is still good, this room type needs to take the stairs to carry luggage and the price is set to be 50% off on the day."
★★★★★
2026-07-31
G

Guest User

Solo traveler
La Jolla Resort ★★
"The room was ok. The bathroom ceiling was very low and small shower. But the location is great by the water. Very expensive for what it was."
★★★★★
2025-03-19
G

Guest User

Couple
Breezy Palms Resort ★★
"We had an amazing relaxing time at Breezy Palms resort!!! We stayed in a 1st floor ocean front apartment that was recently updated, very clean and had a great view of the ocean. Nice to have the full kitchen-used every day. Bathroom was just right and had great shower! Bed was comfortable and great sheets!Screened lanai was perfect. Pool was wonderful, clean and warmer than the ocean! There is nice small beach with sand here. We didn’t get a chance to use the outdoor BBQs, but they looked well maintained, clean, and had everything for grilling. Office staff was friendly and helpful. Fully stocked on site store with bait, snacks, clothing, bottled soft drinks, Blue Bunny ice cream treats, and toiletries. Great maintenance throughout the resort. Although on Route 1, we didn’t hear the highway - lots of roosters and birds chirping. Iguanas were cool to see every day. They have a great dock to fish off of and we did fish for the last 3 days (got a 3 day salt water shore fishing license from nearby bait & tackle store) off the concrete dock and caught a grunt, pinfish, & 28” tarpon - all released. This location was great for seeing all of the keys because it’s a mile marker 80. Walking to nearby restaurants, marina and bridge to see sunset was within 1/4 mile - we could have used the bicycles, but didn’t bring the right footwear for biking. Breezy Palms resort was awesome!! Definitely a place for everyone - couples, families & solo travelers."
★★★★★
2026-04-21
G

GB Guest User

Couple
Islander Resort ★★★★
"Nice hotel rooms that you can drive up to. Nice amount of space—although the bathroom is very small. Pool area is ok, not enough umbrellas. Didn’t get water everyday despite being told it was included with the resort fee. The access to the sea isn’t great. Yoga was fantastic."
★★★★★
2023-08-23
G

ES Guest User

Family
Amara Cay Resort ★★★★
"We love this hotel , we will definitely return 🤩"
★★★★★
2026-06-02
G

GB Guest User

Solo traveler
Fisher Inn Resort & Marina ★★★
"NO HOT WATER! I read previous reviews after and the same thing happened to them! So this has been going on for days! (Block 3) So deceitful of the hotel not to take the rooms off the booking sites! Diabolical they are still selling the king rooms. **BREACH OF CONTRACT — STANDARD AMENITY** They offered a paltry $50 off to stay! I had paid Trip and wouldn’t get the refund in time to book another hotel at 6pm! So had no choice but to keep the reservation. On top of all that, the bed was terrible, the springs creak! Sound proofing is non existent (see previous reviews also)"
★★☆☆☆
2025-03-29
G

Guest User

Family
La Siesta Resort & Villas ★★★★
"Check in super easy.  Nice resort."
★★★★★
2026-06-30

Useful Information for Your Trip to Islamorada

Power Plug & Voltage

120V/Type A/B

💵

Exchange Rate

1 AED ≈ 0.27 USD

💳

Local Payment

Cards/ApplePay/Cash

📱

Connectivity

Verizon/AT&T/T-Mobile

🌡️

Current Weather

Clear

More Islamorada hotel info

Data type

Details

Number of Reviews

2,463

Total Properties

57

Weekday Avg. Price

AED 1,433

Weekend Avg. Price

AED 1,806

Trending hotel

Cheeca Lodge & Spa

Islamorada hotel FAQs

Disclaimer: This article has been provided by an individual contributor or third party platform. If there is any discrepancy regarding the copyright, please contact us directly and we will delete the content immediately.